I am interested in trading a 1936 Luger P08 for a colt 1911 Gold Cup Match. I think the value of the Luger is $1200 to $1600. The Luger is in good condition, but has a non matching part and no holster for the gun. Will this be a fair trade for a 1911 in new condition? I haven't yet found a 1911 trade.

If you are trying to get a ballpark price - I'd suggest watching the gun auctions, probably your best bet. Average 3 or 4 so one screwy price doesn't throw things out of line.

You might get some more informed opinions on Lugers over at www.surplusrifle.com forums, hope that helps.